Exec Summary
- New 303 Page FINCEN/OFAC Rule, aligns to the clear language of the Genius act, but IMHO will create major friction for use of USD stablecoins in eCommerce
- Rules for tracking parties and monitoring secondary activity create a compliance regime that burdens every party with the need to understand the provenance of a coin. Can you imagine accepting $2000 for a new TV, shipping it out, then having your stablecoins burned?
- So not only do we have KYC but we have SAR reporting requirements as PPSIs must also comply with SAR and the “Travel Rule” (31 CFR 1010.410(f)), which involves collecting and transmitting information about the originators and beneficiaries of funds transmittal.
- Banks and Stablecoin Issuers that jumpted into Solana’s Token-2022 model saw this coming and are well placed to move forward
- This creates substantial advantages for banks in sweeping coins into covered accounts and freshly minting new coins when required.
- Great news for Big Banks and V/MA. card gain signficant advantage over stablecoins with the proposed rule
- I see this as tailwind for stablecoins in settlement, but a big headwind for stablecoin in eCommerce (with a few exceptions).
- My views on Stablecoin winners and losers remain unchanged except for an update to winners for x402.
- No wonder Jamie Dimon remains confident that the banks will win, it will take years for stablecoin startups to build the regulatory muscle required to manage 303 pages of FinCEN mandates. By the time they do, the banks will already be running their own stablecoin subsidiaries under the very same rules.
The Rule
The U.S. Treasury’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) and OFAC issued a 303-page proposed rule implementing the GENIUS Act, reclassifying permitted payment stablecoin issuers (PPSIs) as financial institutions under the Bank Secrecy Act. Requirements include bank-grade KYC, suspicious activity reporting, transaction blocking/freezing capabilities, and appointment of a U.S.-based compliance officer. Enforcement begins January 2027. A 60-day comment period opens now.
The NPRM (Notice of Proposed Rulemaking) introduces 31 CFR Part 1033, which specifically outlines the obligations of PPSIs. The density of this document reflects the complexity of applying traditional banking rules to a distributed ledger environment.